Golden Retriever Club of South Australia INC

GRCSA - 2003 Champ Show Critique

 16TH AUGUST 2003

JUDGE:  MRS WENDY ANDREWS (U K)

 

I would like to thank the Members and the Committee of the Golden Retriever Club of South Australia for inviting me to judge your prestigious show and for the days spent amongst you all afterwards.  I really enjoyed seeing and going over your dogs, and will give you my comments and impressions on those at the beginning of my report.  I also had opportunity to talk with members in the days following the show, about your dogs and other matters which concern our lovely breed and I think we all learnt much from each other.  I particularly enjoyed the afternoon of gundog training down on the beach!

Thank you all for giving me such a nice welcome and for many happy memories to treasure from ‘down under’. If you ever come to England – please look me up!

GENERAL IMPRESSIONS OF THE DOGS

Overall on the plus side, I found your Australian Golden Retrievers to excel in toplines and in stifle angulation.  Heads and feet were also very good and I found few dubious mouths. 

I was impressed with the standard of ringcraft training of the dogs (especially your baby puppies!) and the show preparation of the exhibits was excellent.

On the minus side I felt that your dogs generally did not carry enough substance and were in some cases painfully thin.  A lot were on the bottom end of the breed standard for size too.

The most prevalent and overriding fault was the lack of well angulated shoulders and correct length of the upper arm.  We have this problem in England (and in other Countries around the world too). But in the UK we also have many dogs with superb shoulders assemblies.  Sadly, I found very few good shoulders amongst the dogs in Australia when I judged.

As a breeder, I have found that good shoulders are the most difficult thing to get right and it may take 6 generations of selective breeding to do so. On the other hand, good stifle angulation you can breed in one generation!  This needs watching for the future.

 

Baby Puppy Dog

1st.  Hall’s BEAUCROFT INTRUDER     

A confident, happy mover with waggy tail.  He took this class for his overall balance and good shoulder and stifle angulation.  Good feet. Level topline, promising head with sweet expression.  Profuse coat.

2nd  Davis’s TAMESIS RIVERDANCE

A lovely well angulated puppy that grew in confidence as the class progressed. Head needs to develop, but this should come.

3rd. Braithwaite’s TAUMAC GOLDEN CASANOVA

Very well presented puppy and so full of confidence.  In good coat and moving well.  Gentlest of heads and expressions. A little straight in stifle.

 

Minor Puppy Dog

1st. Harrowfield’s SAVANETA WORTH THE WAIT

Lovely head with good pigmentation. Nicely balanced both standing and on the move with happy tail action.  Needs to grow on.

2nd.  Krajnc’s LEIGHVALLEY HELLRAISER.

Good profile when standing but too narrow in front.  Did not move as well as first.

3rd.  Koschade’s BOOLAROO ERROL FLYNN

Has promise but today spoilt his chances by leaning heavily to one side, throwing his front out of alignment.  Still very young and needs to grow on.

 

Puppy Dog

1st.  Moore’s TIPTREE TAVDRUM TBERWICK

A lot to like in this one, with good angulation fore and aft.  Still needs to fill out.  Today won on his movement as he really covered the ground showing off his level topline and tail carriage.  Well coated, pale youngster with excellent pigmentation.

2nd.  Harrowfield’s GOLDOG ALPINE HYLANDLORD

Very nice indeed. -  a quality puppy, so nicely balanced and with a good head.  Pity he did not carry his tail better when on the move.

3rd.  Goodall and Rammell’s SAVANETA BELIEVE IT OR NOT

Also moved with his tail down!  He has a lovely head, good bone and plenty of substance.  Could do with better shoulder angulation though.

 

Junior Dog

1st.  Brice’s COOINDA GOLDEN DESTINY  

A well balanced youngster with level topline, good bend of stifles, straight front.  Good head with excellent pigmentation and gentle expression.  Moved very well with long free stride.

2nd. Stapylton’s GILTEDGE SOUTERN STORM.

Presented in beautiful pale coat in full bloom. Full of ring presence, showing and moving with confidence and style.  Front could be straighter and head a little overdone for me.  Excellent bend of stifle.

3rd Harding’s GOLDOG ALPHINE JAIME

Liked this one for his good bend of stifle. Well “let down” hocks, good feet.  Just found his neckline into withers too angular, but otherwise a nice one.  Moved and showed well.

 

 

Intermediate Dog

A large class with 21 entries ( 3 abs )  The standard here was very pleasing indeed.

1st.  Cooke’s GOLDEW DREAM WEAVER.    Best Intermediate

Caught my eye immediately for his balance and overall quality.  Correct angulation of both shoulders and stifles, neat hocks, level topline which he held on the move. Head well chisselled with kindly expression.  Moved soundly, covering the ground with free easy strides.

2nd. Clark’s NARA GOLD MERLIN

Another quality dog. Compact and with correct angulation of shoulder and stifle.  Not a big one but everything nicely balanced.  Good head, well muscled neck into level topline, straight front. Moved soundly and with drive.  Good coat and condition.

3rd Beaucroft Kennels.  GILTEDGE THE GAMBLER.

Paler dog in super coat and gleaming condition.  When standing, tends to pull forward which tended to spoil his topline, but I saw enough of his true outline to forgive him a little!  Good neck, shoulders and bend of stifle. A nice dog.

4th. Taumac Kennels CH. TAUMAC COURT JESTER

Beautifully presented and in lovely coat. More pigmentation on nose and a slightly darker eye needed, but otherwise a very nice dog who moved extremely well with power and drive.

5th. Hillyer’s WYANDRA AUTUMN DAZE

Gleaming coat of darker colour.  Well put together with level topline, good straight front with elbows well tucked in.  Good bone and excellent cat-like feet. Moved well.

 

 

State Bred Dog

1st Goodall & Rammell’s CH. SAVANETA CARRIBEAN DREAM   Best State Bred

Caught my eye for his strong, true movement and lovely head carriage.  Excellent hindquarters and good forehand.  Very nice indeed.

2nd.  Braithwaite’s BRACKENDELL INA RIVER

A rangier dog still needing to mature and fill his frame.  Good construction, correct true movement.  Good round bone and cat-like feet.

3rd.  Reimann’s  BOURNBEAU SIR JAMES

Masculine head with gentle expression Sound strong quarters with good bend of stifle.  Good front, level topline.  Sound mover.

 

 

Australian Bred Dog

1. Handley’s GILTEDGE TICKET TO RIDE      Challenge Dog and Reserve Best in Show and Best Opposite Sex in Show

Later found out that he is still very young, but one has to judge on the day and for me he  stood out as an eye-catching, quality dog.  In full bloom, balanced, compact, with excellent shoulder angulation and upper arm of correct length, giving a good forechest and placing his legs well under his body.  Good spring of rib and carrying the right amount of weight. Level topline and good bend of stifle.  Masculine, well chiseled head, with dark pigmentation.  Moved superbly – will trouble the best.

2. Hodges’s CH. CAMUKA MONARCH OF THE GLEN  Reserve Dog Challenge

Another dog of quality.  Close up to winner and unlucky to meet him on such good form. Well constructed, masculine head with soft expression. Plenty of substance with good spring of rib.  Good  front and good shoulder and stifle angulation.  Really drove from the rear when moving.  Liked him a lot!

3. Fall’s CH. FERNFALL SEA LEGEND

Good in all essentials with a lovely head and gentle kindly expression.  Soundly made all through.  Showed and moved well and thoroughly deserved his placing in this quality class.

4. Kowalski’s AMBERVALLEY ERIK CASIMIR

Bigger frame but with plenty of substance and good bone. Nice head and expression.  Shoulders not as good as others. Showed and moved well.

 

 

Open Dog

Little to separate one and two who were both on top form and in beautiful bloom.  The placings were mainly decided on movement.

1st  Krajnc’s CH. LEIGHVALLEY FAMENFORTUNE

Lovely head and head carriage, super neck flowing into level topline.  Straight front, good shoulder placement and well bent stifles.  Moved truly, accurately and effortlessly.

2nd. Dulke’s FANTANGO PURPLE REIGN

Very close up – again a lovely head with soft expression.  Good shoulder angulation both fore and aft.  Level topline.  Not moving today as positively as winner but a quality  dog never-the-less!

3rd. Braithwaite’s CH. MONTEGO MITY CLASSY

Nice type, sound all through and moving with style.  Good in all essentials with straight front, level topline. Nicely presented.

4th Beaucroft’s CH. BEAUCROFT THE BRIGADIER

Soundly made, balanced dog who strode out well when moving.  Good bone and feet and in lovely coat and condition.

 

 

Neutered Dog

1. Daffern’s CH. GOLDENFIRE SIR GWILYM       Best Neuter

2. Daffern’s  CH. TAMEROSE BRACKEN CD ET

My notes say ‘peas in a pod’ and little to separate except aging.  When I look in my catalogue I can see why!  Sir Gwilym just had the edge over his sire Bracken on his powerful and positive movement.  Both were in tip top condition and presented to perfection and thoroughly enjoying their day out!  A credit to their owners.

 

 

Baby Puppy Bitch

1st. Taumac’s  TAUMAC PLAYGIRLS GOLD

Looking good for her age with everything developing as it should. Nicely balanced and articulated.  Happy personality who showed and moved with confidence.

2nd. Hill’s BEAUCROFT GAME OCHANCE

Super baby with the sweetest of heads and expressions.  Well made with correct bend of stifle, neat hocks, level topline.  Should do well.

3rd Braithwaite’s TAUMAC GOLD FOR CAROL

Another nice one showing promise for the future. Good head, coat and condition.  So well trained and showing like a veteran.

 

 

Minor Puppy Bitch

1st. Goldshyne’s DOBRO GOLD SHINE      Best Minor Puppy

Correctly constructed with a lot to like.  Feminine head with gentle expression.  Good coat and condition.  Level topline and well bent stifles.  Moved and showed well.

2nd. Goodall & Rammell’s SAVANETA ALMOST HEAVEN

More mature than first and close up.  I just preferred winners overall angulation.   But she is a well balanced puppy with time on her side.  I really fell for her sweet head and expression though.

3rd Jenkins’s SOVANNA GOLDEN GEORGET

A real baby, having a lovely time, who would not stand still for her handler! She has a lovely head, super straight front, tight feet and good bend of stifle. Moved with animation.

 

 

PUPPY BITCH

This class was not a particularly good one, lacking quality in depth.

1st. Molnar’s DOBRO CHILLI VANILLI      Best Puppy

Won this class with ease. Sweetest of heads, straight front, good bend of stifle, level topline which she held on the move.  Showed and handled well.

2nd. Hodges’s CAMUKA VOULEZ VOUS

Feminine head with gentle expression.  Pleasing outline with a good neck flowing into topline. Nicely bent stifles. Needs more substance.

3rd. Hallion’s GOLDOG ALPINE HYLANDROSE

Excels in hindquarters which are well muscled and firm with good bend of stifle.   Her front is not as good as she is rather loose at elbow and needs to tighten still. Happy personality and showed well. 

 

 

Junior Bitch

1st. Goodall & Rammell’s SAVANETA HEARTS ON FIRE

Particularly liked her head and expression. Good reach of neck into level topline and well set on tail. Good spring of rib with elbows well tucked in. Good bend of stifle with depth across the quarters. Moved at one with her handler.

2. Harrowfield’s GOLDOG ALPHINE HYLANDMIST

Very  nice youngster with plenty of substance and good straight bone. Tight cat-like feet. Well  balanced, compact with level topline which she held on the move.  In beautiful coat and condition.

3rd Edwards’s FERNFALL PICTURE PERFECT

Balanced, animated and happy bitch with plenty of substance and a waggy tail. Gave her handler a hard time as she was very fidgety! I saw enough of her to like her! Moved well.

 

 

Intermediate Bitch

A nice class full of quality, with hair splitting decisions at the end.

1st. Beaucroft’s TAUMAC GOLDEN CRYSTAL

A sweet headed bitch, with such a gentle expression. Nicely balanced and well made all through and presented in immaculate coat and condition, but just needing a little more tummy feathering to complete the picture.  Moved particularly well which won her the class.

2nd Clark’s GOLDFLEECE MUSCATEL

Liked this one a lot and thought she might be my winner here today but she would not move with any sparkle. A pity, as there was so much to like about her. Presented in lovely coat.

3rd. Krajnc’s CH. WILLOWCROFT LIBERTY BELL

A bigger bitch, full of substance with good spring of rib and deep at the brisket. Good, straight bone and tight feet.  Correctly constructed with well laid shoulders and good bend of stifle.  Well presented and showing with animation.  Head just a bit heavy for me.

4th Biggs’s GOLDOG ALPINE TRULY TRUDY

Darker and shown in gleaming condition.  Very soundly made all through. Not as good in shoulders as those above.

 

 

State Bred Bitch

Generally this class did not impress.

1st Hillyer’s CH. WYANDRA HEART BREAKER

Well put together with nice head and good reach of neck.  Level topline, good bone and feet correct bend of stifle.  Well presented and in very good condition.

2nd. Goodall & Rammell’s CH. SAVANETA FIRE N ICE

Very nice head and alert yet gentle expression.  Soundly made with good topline and strong hindquarters.  Moved well and at one with her handler.

3rd. Wallis’s BOOLAROO MISTLETOE HOLLY

Not as well balanced as those above and needing a better layback of shoulder.  In good coat and condition. Moved and showed well.

 

 

Australian Bred Bitch

1st. Goodall & Rammell’s CH. SAVANETA TAHITI SWEETIE

A lovely bitch of quality with so much to like.  Well chiseled, feminine head with sweet expression.  Good reach of neck into well laid shoulders. Level topline, good angulation of stifle, tail well set on.  In super coat and condition and moving with drive and precision.

2nd Taumac’s CH. TAUMAC GOLD FOR SUSIE

Eyecatching on the move, she really powered around the ring.  Sweet head and expression and presented so well with gleaming full coat. Preferred  shoulder and stifle angulation of winner.

3rd Sommer’s GOLDOG ALPINE OPHELIA

Well bodied with good spring of rib and deep chest, excellent bend of stifle. Tail set and tail carriage a bit high.  Very nicely presented and moved so well.

4th Daffern’s CH. BOOLAROO REMINISCE

Bitch with a lovely head and expression. Longer cast than those above.  In super coat and condition and moved with style

 

 

Open Bitch

Over all quality of exhibits in this class was very pleasing

1st. Handley’s CH. GILTEDGE TARA 

Bitch Challenge and Best in show

An outstanding bitch from any angle. Caught my eye immediately for her type and quality.

Superb outline and in full bloom.  Head held proudly on well arched neck. Good shoulders, topline and deep well muscled quarters with excellent bend of stifle.  Happy waggy tail and moving most positively and accurately.  I would quite happily have smuggled her home with me! My star of the day .

2nd. Beaucroft’s CH. BEAUCROFT BY DESIGN

Reserve Bitch Challenge.

Another quality bitch with good layback of shoulders and strong well muscled quarters.  Level topline and good tail set.  Well let down hocks and good feet.  So well balanced with deep mature body. Moved so truly.  I liked her enormously.

3rd Dulke’s CH. AVONBREEZE PRUDENT

Paler bitch in very good coat and showing her head off.  At one with her handler both standing and on the move. Sweetest of heads and expressions.  A nice one.

4th Kowalski’s AMBERVALLEY GERI HALIWELL

Superb pigmentation and gentle expression.  Not as well angulated as those above and a bit apprehensive at times.  Moved very well though

 

 

Neuter Bitch

1st. Knight’s HOLMCROFT LUCY DIAMONDS

Lovely head and expression, correct length of neck, good bone and feet. Compact and well put together.   Shown in full coat.  Moved well.

2nd. Goodall’s  CHIPALA HAVE A LITTLE FAITH

A nice bitch, sound and well made with a lot to like. Shown in good coat and moving correctly A small ‘cowlick’ spoiled her expression for me.

3rd. Frederick’s YAQUI’S BUNDLE OF JOY

Good head, neck, topline and bend of stifle.  Tail set on low.  Moved and showed well.

 

[ BACK TO CHAMPIONSHIPS SHOWS ]